7.16.2013

The Power of Questions and Feelings of Discomfort

“Discomfort brings engagement and change. Discomfort means you're doing something that others were unlikely to do, because they're hiding out in the comfortable zone. ” 




I have two boys, one a rising 3rd grader and the other a rising 5th grader. Because we live in the country, their school bus arrives promptly to pick them up before the rooster crows.  For this reason, I have driven them to school every day since Kindergarten so we can leave after the sun has risen. However, I think the real reason I chose to drive them to school was a little more selfish on my part - I just wanted to spend a little more time with them.  I imagined a charming ride conversing about their hopes, dreams, and wishes in life.  In reality, our car ride has been comprised of 15 minutes of intricate questions posed by my boys - questions ranging from how to raise a pig or string a lacrosse stick to the thickness of the electrical lines or the inner workings of a generator.   Questions that I do not know how to answer because they are topics that simply are not on my radar.  By the time I arrive at their school, I find that I am so flustered and uncomfortable by their barrage of questions, as well as my ineptness in answering them, that I have erased all desires for our special time together.  Instead, I am filled with joy when I unload my boys in front of their school in the capable hands of the librarian, the perfect person to answer their questions!

I am an Instructional Coach for Albemarle County Public Schools.  Prior to this, I wore many hats.  I was a special education case manager, a reading specialist, a transition specialist, and a collaborative English teacher.  This past Spring, I was asked by a teacher, who did not know me in my previous life, what my expertise was.   Our County's coaching model assumes that Instructional Coaches are generalists not specialists, embedded professional development for teachers as they focus on the process of teaching.  As I fumbled for words to find an answer for this teacher, my county's Director of K-12 Education calmly jumped in and said, "Her expertise is questioning.  The Instructional Coaches are experts in asking questions."  Wow! Such a succinct answer, but such a true answer.  I have never thought of myself as an expert in questioning, but it is something that I now do every day when I am working with teachers.

When I first embarked on my career as an instructional coach, I balked at the questioning stems provided to me for my conversations with teachers.  What was the big deal about these question stems? As a veteran teacher, I comfortably spoke and collaborated with teachers, thought I had all of the answers, and prided myself in being able to provide a menu of options to them.  What I realize now is that using these question stems initially made me feel very uncomfortable because they were something new to me - they were not in the realm of my comfort zone.  However, they came to grow on me. Lately, instead of just talking to teachers, I find I have been asking tons of meddlesome questions - just like my boys! The teachers with whom I work have me constantly wondering with genuine curiosity. It isn't until now, as I start on my fourth year of coaching, that I realize the power of asking these questions to teachers.  They are questions that sit with teachers and gnaw at them late at night. Questions that drive inquiry, bring a nagging discomfort, and result in a nudge leading to an adventure in a whole new world. 

This past year, a teacher lamented to me about grading the papers for all of her 140 students.  I didn't empathize or commiserate.  Instead, I found myself wondering aloud to her  about the possibility of "flipping" feedback to all those students using screen casting technologies. I did this using my "I wonder what would happen if..." questioning stem without thinking - it just naturally burst out of my mouth.  I will never forget the look this teacher gave me -  a look like I had just landed from Mars and had three heads.  She quickly and emphatically exclaimed, "No way!"  And with that one question, she ditched me as expeditiously as I unloaded my boys from my car.  A week later, that same teacher sought me out and thanked me for my question.  She had tinkered with the technology and found a way to provide more meaningful feedback to her students.  This year, she is embarking on creating a digital writing workshop in her classroom.  Another teacher recounted the events of her new blended teaching practices in a presentation to the school board stating, "It all started with one question from an Instructional Coach."

Although, I only asked simple questions, these two teachers embraced them and wrestled with them.   They allowed themselves to reflect, to be nudged and to be irritated by a question, which ultimately has led them on new adventures in their educational careers.  Furthermore, they brought me along on their wonderful and wild ride.  It is on these adventures that I have learned so much from and been in awe of each teacher's ability to allow themselves to be uncomfortable, really uncomfortable.  It takes great strength to do this. These teachers are now leaders in their school, the county, and their wider professional learning network. They are not only facilitating meaningful learning with their students, but also their colleagues.

So, maybe questions aren't so bad after all.  Even my boys' simple questions about farm animals, sports equipment, and machines have been a blessing.  Inevitably, at some point in my day, I find myself googling "raising pigs" or whatever their inquiry of the day is.  I google because curiosity nudges and pokes me.  Had these teachers or I never experienced (and seized) the discomfort resulting from a few simple questions, we might never have understood their power to drive change. How true it is that "Life begins at the end of your comfort zone."