Showing posts with label Questions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Questions. Show all posts

9.25.2015

Why Do Bad Things Happen to Good People?

I received a card in the mail this past week from one of the first year teachers I worked with last year.  (By the way, cards rock!  I have saved every card sent to me!)  It was such a pleasure to get to hang out with this teacher all year, and I know she is impacting the lives of so many kiddos!  She has an amazing soul and is constantly reflecting on everything in her life, so I wasn't surprised when one of the first lines in her card was a question she was struggling with: "Why do bad things happen to good people?"

Awesome question!  It is a question that zipped through my head when I initially learned of my breast cancer diagnosis, although I admit that I didn't feel like a super "good" person...I still have my share of faults.  However, it was a question that my husband wrestled with for a while longer.

One night, as we were headed to bed, Marty asked me how I was doing.  I told him that I was okay...that I was at peace...that somehow I knew deep within me that God was watching over me.  Finally, I told him that I had come to the realization that this was God's plan for me and I just needed to figure out what He wanted me to do with it.  In knowing all of this, I could finally sleep at night.

When I finished this long explanation to his short question, I looked at Marty, and clearly remember his response, "Well, I am not there yet with God. I wish I was."  Lights off...and off to sleep we went...or rather off to sleep I went.

Sometime that night, Marty had this vivid dream or nightmare or both about how he was building a church for Clayton Jennings here in Charlottesville.  If you do not know who Clayton Jennings is, no worries!  I had absolutely no idea who he was until Marty stumbled across him (with the nudging of his cousin) a couple of months ago.  He is a young guy who is running around everywhere trying to bring people to God.  At his breakneck pace, Marty can't understand how he hasn't burnt out.  Marty follows him on Facebook and gets updates on his work from Zimbabwe to Richmond, VA to Kentucky.

Back to Marty's dream...In the dream, he was having a horrible argument with Clayton Jennings about building the church.  The dispute in his dream was so bad that it woke Marty up. Marty, got up, dragged himself to the living room, and did what many of us do when we can't sleep - open a laptop to mindlessly stare at Facebook!

What do you know! The first thing that popped up on his timeline on FB was a post from Clayton Jennings - a video entitled, "Why Do Bad Things Happen to God's People?"  And, it was posted at the exact same time Marty and I were having our conversation before going to sleep! Here it is...take a few minutes and watch it...trust me:


After seeing this, Marty came running into our room with his laptop in one hand and shook me awake with the other free hand.  He kept excitedly saying, "Laura, you've got to see this!  Wake up!  You have to watch this now!"  Now, I was in the middle of my own dreams, but I groggily came to and set his computer on my lap.  And as I watched, tears of sadness AND joy streamed endlessly down my cheeks.  I finally had an small answer for what God's plan was for me...I am going to help Him make beautiful music.  So cool!  

In his video, Clayton talks about how God, like a piano tuner, sometimes needs to stretch chords to an unimaginable tightness.  Ironically, I have something the medical professionals are calling "chording" going on underneath my arms.  My muscles and ligaments are so tight that they really feel like guitar or piano strings.  This "chording" is what is hindering my perfect range of motion in my arms.  So, when I get frustrated, I remind myself that maybe the chording is my physical reminder of God stretching me beyond what I could ever imagine.

To this day, I am still not sure how I will help make beautiful music, but I will try any way I can. I am excited to one day to discover how I  will play a part in His orchestra, how He will play beautiful music through me.  I am ready!  

In the meantime, Marty can now sleep at night.  I guess Clayton helped him, in a small way, "get there" with God.  And, I have a magnificent answer to share with my beautiful friend when she asks me, "Why do bad things happen to good people?"

3.05.2014

Navigating Readers and Reading

http://luciediamonds.deviantart.com/art/Lost-In-A-Good-Book-174529828

I just finished Navigating Early by Clare Vanderpool.  I read it not only because I pledged to read 40 books this year or because there is a bunch of hype out about this book, but because I have a son in 5th grade for whom I am constantly trying to find enticing books.  Books that he can just get lost in.



Navigating Early is about two boys who embark on a quest to find the infamous great bear deep in the woods of Maine on the Appalachian Trail.  One of the main characters, Early, is complex, and it takes going on this trip for his friend, Jack, to figure him out - to truly navigate him, as well as figure out the direction in which his own life was taking him.

Before I became an instructional coach, I was a high school collaborative English teacher pursuing a degree in Reading Education.  In class, I stood on my head to make literature exciting for my students.  I wanted my kids to love reading as much as I did.  Ironically, I was trying to help them find this passion for and flow with reading through works like Homer's The Odyssey, Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet and Othello, and Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales.

Have I mentioned I taught struggling readers?  I got pretty creative with my lessons, and my kids either seemed to like the novels-plays-very old pieces of writing by dead white men, OR they were just being nice to me because I was expending so much energy helping them understand what they were reading.  I was really doing all of the sweating, not my kids.

Now that I look back, I never once saw my students feel the need jump out of their seats after class, sprint to the library, and check out another one of those classic books in the canon for which high school English teachers are notorious.  I am not advocating ditching the teaching of these famous classics - Kelly Gallagher states in his book Readicide that it is important to teach kids how to navigate them.  Furthermore, it is important to find the balance of not under-teaching or over-teaching these classics, in addition to augmenting with real life reading.  But, how do we do this while building their own love of and interest in reading?



Now that I have my own struggling "I-really-wish-I-could-read-like-everyone-else" reader, I understand that intense desire to pour over a book is truly there, especially one that seems exciting. It's just the letters, words, and even type of book get in the way.  He tries with all of his heart to decipher the words on each page on his own, but I know he stumbles over most of them and only manages to only get a gist of what he is reading. The plot of Navigating Early couldn't be better suited for my adventurous, outdoor-loving son.  He picked it up and really tried to read it, but could not get past the first chapter on his own.  For other kids, they might be able to read all of the words fluently, but have no background knowledge to aid them with understanding the concepts they are reading.  They too, only get the gist of what they are reading.  Just like the students Gallagher was speaking about in his first video.

So back to navigating readers.  How do we really get to know our readers?  How do we find out what they like to read?  How do we find books they are comfortable with reading to help them build fluency?  How do we give them time to read what they want in addition to giving them time to read real world material?  How do we navigate them, as readers, to help us know what they are struggling with in the text.  And how do we help them navigate reading so that it is an amazing experience?  

I am grappling with all of these questions as I read the following books by Donalyn Miller, Penny Kittle, Kylene Beers, and Chris Lehman.  In the meantime, I will download the audio version of Navigating Early for my son so he can get lost in the book without spending most of his time tripping over the words.



Fun Resources I Have Found Along the Way

As a first step, check out the following links.  They provide exciting reading material that kindles curiosity and builds knowledge - they might tie in to some of your content area reading!

Elementary and Middle School


High School 

Article of the Week (Resources from Kelly Gallagher)









7.16.2013

The Power of Questions and Feelings of Discomfort

“Discomfort brings engagement and change. Discomfort means you're doing something that others were unlikely to do, because they're hiding out in the comfortable zone. ” 




I have two boys, one a rising 3rd grader and the other a rising 5th grader. Because we live in the country, their school bus arrives promptly to pick them up before the rooster crows.  For this reason, I have driven them to school every day since Kindergarten so we can leave after the sun has risen. However, I think the real reason I chose to drive them to school was a little more selfish on my part - I just wanted to spend a little more time with them.  I imagined a charming ride conversing about their hopes, dreams, and wishes in life.  In reality, our car ride has been comprised of 15 minutes of intricate questions posed by my boys - questions ranging from how to raise a pig or string a lacrosse stick to the thickness of the electrical lines or the inner workings of a generator.   Questions that I do not know how to answer because they are topics that simply are not on my radar.  By the time I arrive at their school, I find that I am so flustered and uncomfortable by their barrage of questions, as well as my ineptness in answering them, that I have erased all desires for our special time together.  Instead, I am filled with joy when I unload my boys in front of their school in the capable hands of the librarian, the perfect person to answer their questions!

I am an Instructional Coach for Albemarle County Public Schools.  Prior to this, I wore many hats.  I was a special education case manager, a reading specialist, a transition specialist, and a collaborative English teacher.  This past Spring, I was asked by a teacher, who did not know me in my previous life, what my expertise was.   Our County's coaching model assumes that Instructional Coaches are generalists not specialists, embedded professional development for teachers as they focus on the process of teaching.  As I fumbled for words to find an answer for this teacher, my county's Director of K-12 Education calmly jumped in and said, "Her expertise is questioning.  The Instructional Coaches are experts in asking questions."  Wow! Such a succinct answer, but such a true answer.  I have never thought of myself as an expert in questioning, but it is something that I now do every day when I am working with teachers.

When I first embarked on my career as an instructional coach, I balked at the questioning stems provided to me for my conversations with teachers.  What was the big deal about these question stems? As a veteran teacher, I comfortably spoke and collaborated with teachers, thought I had all of the answers, and prided myself in being able to provide a menu of options to them.  What I realize now is that using these question stems initially made me feel very uncomfortable because they were something new to me - they were not in the realm of my comfort zone.  However, they came to grow on me. Lately, instead of just talking to teachers, I find I have been asking tons of meddlesome questions - just like my boys! The teachers with whom I work have me constantly wondering with genuine curiosity. It isn't until now, as I start on my fourth year of coaching, that I realize the power of asking these questions to teachers.  They are questions that sit with teachers and gnaw at them late at night. Questions that drive inquiry, bring a nagging discomfort, and result in a nudge leading to an adventure in a whole new world. 

This past year, a teacher lamented to me about grading the papers for all of her 140 students.  I didn't empathize or commiserate.  Instead, I found myself wondering aloud to her  about the possibility of "flipping" feedback to all those students using screen casting technologies. I did this using my "I wonder what would happen if..." questioning stem without thinking - it just naturally burst out of my mouth.  I will never forget the look this teacher gave me -  a look like I had just landed from Mars and had three heads.  She quickly and emphatically exclaimed, "No way!"  And with that one question, she ditched me as expeditiously as I unloaded my boys from my car.  A week later, that same teacher sought me out and thanked me for my question.  She had tinkered with the technology and found a way to provide more meaningful feedback to her students.  This year, she is embarking on creating a digital writing workshop in her classroom.  Another teacher recounted the events of her new blended teaching practices in a presentation to the school board stating, "It all started with one question from an Instructional Coach."

Although, I only asked simple questions, these two teachers embraced them and wrestled with them.   They allowed themselves to reflect, to be nudged and to be irritated by a question, which ultimately has led them on new adventures in their educational careers.  Furthermore, they brought me along on their wonderful and wild ride.  It is on these adventures that I have learned so much from and been in awe of each teacher's ability to allow themselves to be uncomfortable, really uncomfortable.  It takes great strength to do this. These teachers are now leaders in their school, the county, and their wider professional learning network. They are not only facilitating meaningful learning with their students, but also their colleagues.

So, maybe questions aren't so bad after all.  Even my boys' simple questions about farm animals, sports equipment, and machines have been a blessing.  Inevitably, at some point in my day, I find myself googling "raising pigs" or whatever their inquiry of the day is.  I google because curiosity nudges and pokes me.  Had these teachers or I never experienced (and seized) the discomfort resulting from a few simple questions, we might never have understood their power to drive change. How true it is that "Life begins at the end of your comfort zone."