9.16.2013

Who inspires your creativity?

The concept of creativity has been looming in my thoughts lately.  It seems that everywhere I turn, the topic of creativity pops up.  Throughout the past weeks, teachers in one of the schools I am coaching have been delving into the 4C's - the school's focus for the year.  The 4 C's include collaboration, communication, critical thinking, and creativity.  (Our county has added an additional 2 C's, which are choice and comfort.)  About the same time as I was listening to teachers grapple with which "C" they want to hone in on for the next couple of weeks, I came across a twitter post sharing "10 Ways to Build Critical Thinking."  Number Three on the list is to "Build Creativity."   The following outlines the strategies teachers should take in order to build creativity:

"Rather than providing detailed directions for students to complete an activity, simply make available any necessary materials, then step back and allow kids to use their creativity. Teachers might be surprised at the quality of work that students can produce when they control their own learning."

I also noticed another twitter post asking "Who is your muse? Who inspires your creativity?"  I am not sure who inspires my creativity; however, I do know that my son is constantly teaching me about it.  Furthermore, it is through him, I have seen how easy creativity is to squash.

From a very young age, my son had me collecting toilet paper and paper towel rolls for him to tinker with.  He first started with building numerous boats out of the tubes, waterproofing them with my Saran plastic wrap, and testing them in the bathtub.  In addition to the cardboard tubes and plastic wrap, he has gone through so many rolls of tape, spools of cooking twine, aluminum foil, and popsicle sticks that I have stopped counting...as well as fretting over how much I am spending to keep a well stocked kitchen.  He has moved on from the tubes to cardboard boxes, legos, snap circuits, and large sticks for his engineering, building, and inventing.

Teepee building at recess.

Lego Candy Machine - Still needs minor adjustments!

As a mom, I naturally thought his inventions were cool, but never put much more thought to them.  I was just happy that he was busy tinkering and imagining, and not wrestling with his brother!  It wasn't until last year, when he was completing a school project, that I was able to truly look at creativity with deeper meaning and study it through a different lens - the lens of a teacher.

My son's class was creating a "Living Museum" which entailed a research project on a famous person of each students' choice.  He chose Harry Houdini, the great escape artist.  The teacher sent home a description of the project's three required components -- a portrait, a timeline, and an organizer for a speech to be given on the day their "museum" came to life and was opened to the public (aka parents).  

I must preface the rest of this story by letting you know that I have always been somewhat of a goody-two-shoes and an extreme rule and direction follower.  So, when I read the requirements for my son's timeline portion of the project, I saw that he had to create it on a poster board.  Since I believe in following the directions - especially a teacher's directions - I dragged him to Target to buy poster board.

In the art supply section of the store, my son begged me to buy the jumbo-sized pack of construction paper for him, not poster board.  I met his pleas with a recitation of the project requirements as outlined in the project description, and plopped a poster board in our cart.   He followed me through the aisles of Target continuing to beg me to get the construction paper and to put the poster board back. It wasn't until we covered the entire store and hit the register that I finally gave in.  I deployed some awful parenting line like, "Okay, do what you want to do - this is your decision, but you are not following the directions on your paper."

The moment we got home, my son ran to my office with his construction paper and busied himself for over an hour.  Curiosity seized me at this point and I decided to take a peek at his project.  I imagined he had probably stapled a bunch of pieces of construction paper together to create a flimsy, poster board-sized background for his timeline.  

Boy, was I really wrong!  I walked into the room and found a 10 ft. ceiling-to-floor timeline comprised of construction paper chain links attached to numerous pictures of locks.  On each lock was a piece of Harry Houdini's life typed neatly in a paragraph.  

I was in awe.  My son had had the courage to break the rules, not to follow the directions, and take a path other than the one his teacher outlined for him. I felt so ashamed that I had almost made him buy that silly poster board and nearly quelled this creativity. 

Harry Houdini's Chain and Locks Timeline

This experience made me wonder how many times we unknowingly extinguish creativity when we have only good intentions in helping our students navigate the banks of the river.  I know I have spent countless hours developing directions to assist students in understanding the components of a project.  But, how do I make sure that I provide enough guidance without impeding greater critical thinking and creativity?  How do we balance giving kids boundaries, constraints, and scaffolded support so they feel safe, yet at the same time provide enough freedom to let their imaginations run wild? How do we make sure that we just "step back and allow kids to use their creativity...and control their own learning?"





9.13.2013

Is Failure Really Success?

Last year, I had the opportunity to attend a Ridley Lecture at UVA and hear Carol Dweck, Stanford University professor of psychology and Mindset author, speak.  In addition to discussing the concept of growth vs. fixed mindsets, she made a statement that has stuck in the back of my mind: What would it look like if kids embraced the word "yet?"  It is such a small word, but so powerful and full of possibilities!  She talks about the word in the video below:


I work around many students who are paralyzed by perfectionism and by being the best.  They believe they have failed if they receive a grade lower than an "A" on their first attempt.  Furthermore, many throw their hands in the air and give up after that first try or if they are struggling.  How do we help children find opportunity in their perceived failure or struggle?  How do we help children realize that their struggle is really not necessarily negative? Rather, it is a learning opportunity, a chance to try again and gain deeper insight.  How do we help them develop the mindset of not being there "yet" and being totally cool with that?  How do we help children positively embrace the potential of failure like Audri Clemmons did when he tested his Rube Goldberg Monster Catcher:

Embracing Failure with Extreme Excitement - Audri's Rube Goldberg Monster Catcher


I have started collecting quotes that reflect this growth mindset.  Hopefully, they are small reminders to help students realize they are simply not there. . .YET!  And the struggle with getting there is totally worth it.




"I have not failed.  I've just found 10,000 ways that won't work."
- Thomas A. Edison

"You never fail until you stop trying."
- Albert Einstein

"Our greatest glory is not in never failing, but in rising up every time we fail."
- Ralph Waldo Emerson

"It is impossible to live without failing at something, unless you live so cautiously that you might was well not have lived at all - in which case, you fail by default."
- J.K. Rowling

"Only those who dare to fail greatly can ever achieve greatly."
- Robert F. Kennedy

"Success is stumbling from failure to failure with no loss of enthusiasm."
- Winston Churchill